Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stoat's avatar

Let Ann's excellent column serve as a reminder...

~When we named sports teams, cities, towns, roads and landmarks after indians, it was done as a gracious gesture of respect and as an effort to honor indians and their culture. When activists suddenly become offended over this and demand that your city's sports team or river or mountain or whatever be renamed, don't put up a fuss. They never deserved the honor to begin with and your sports team would be far better served with a different name.

~The white settlers to North America didn't 'steal' anybody's land. Brutal warfare was the standard way that real estate exchanged ownership in those days as well as for thousands of years prior. The various indian tribes did that constantly among themselves prior to the arrival of white settlers, and so the idea that what happened was anything more than "we won, you lost, deal with it" is laughable.

~ It was commonplace for a conquering army to kill every last battle-ready enemy warrior they could find and enslave the rest. This was the normal way of life for indians. Everywhere on Earth, throughout human history, It was almost unheard of for the victors to GIVE BACK vast swaths of land to their beaten enemy and allow them autonomous legal control of it, much less to be so kind to them in allowing them to live as they pleased.

~The descriptions of depraved barbarity that Ann includes in her column today are actually rather mild and tame compared with what was commonplace for indian tribes to inflict upon each other on a regular basis, as well as upon the white settlers. I won't go into more detail in deference to any Ladies who might be reading, but for those interested, going back to the original source documents will be a real eye-opener for many, especially younger folks who have only been exposed to the sanitized versions now taught in public schools.

Far from feeling guilty over anything the white settlers did during The Indian Wars, white Americans should feel proud of their forebears, that they conducted themselves with far greater honor and dignity than their enemies did. White settlers truly brought Civilization to North America.

Happy Columbus Day!

Expand full comment
Eye_la's avatar

Happy Columbus day ~

I grew up around many Italian families in Connecticut.

My uncle by marriage, his parents were from Sicily.

Unlike immigrants now they were treated horribly and yes they were legal.

I didn't know until today that my uncle's parents did not know how to read and write in English.

My uncle learned late in life.

Still! They could cook, bake , build and fix anything and everything.

All of this said- I do not need liberal supremacists to tell me what to celebrate and why bc history is debatable and you have to accept the good, bad and ugly of it all.

Today I think of my uncle and am grateful to his parents who treated me like their own.

They never hated America like libs do.

Columbus day was a day to eat Italian food and bakery goods.

Happy Columbus day to all and f'k libs

I am SO sick of hearing about what offends them.

They've ruined America.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts