Discussion about this post

User's avatar
William Hickey's avatar

As a New York Times subscriber I listened to that interview between Ezra Klein and Vivek.

I recorded my immediate impression on X, November 19th:

“Two children of immigrants to this country, neither of whom are Christian, telling Americans what America is.”

Expand full comment
Peter's avatar

Vivek’s point about being American is legally true but ridiculous from a common sense standpoint. Does he truly believe that an Iraqi Muslim coming to US 2 years ago and gaining US citizenship is just as American as George Bush? And one thing I have noticed with liberals (embarrassing that a supposed conservative makes this argument) is that suddenly how long you have been here is important when it comes to “Native Americans “, an expression I loathe.

Expand full comment
38 more comments...

No posts