Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike's avatar

As someone applying to medical school this cycle, trust me it's worse than you can even imagine. The SINGLE MOST common question on secondaries (the supplemental applications sent directly by medical schools) is some variation of "How will you contribute to the ~DiVeRsiTy~ of ____ School of Medicine?" Not to mention the countless other social justice questions you have to answer.

Every school also has a Diversity Equity and Inclusion Board. Yayyy I'll be $300,000 in debt, but at least I'll have a couple dozen "diversity officers" with bloated six figure salaries to harangue me about racism for four years! Two years later and the front page of almost every medical school website is still filled with photos of their activist med students with signs about George Floyd (outside in masks of course).

Last, but certainly not least, affirmative action in medical school is INSANE. It's funny that this article is about Yale because in June when I was discussing schools to apply to with my premed advisor, she literally told me "yeah I don't know much about Yale, I've only gotten black students in there." She then proceeded to burst into laughter. During a one-on-one meeting earlier this year she told me to aim for at least a 515 on the MCAT, but during a meeting with a bunch of other premed students she casually slipped in "yeah and if you are African American probably a 508 is good enough." In undergraduate admissions, affirmative action is at least considered a taboo, but in medical school admissions the disparities are so much more pronounced that they don't even bother trying to downplay it.

There's also no pretense that affirmative action has anything to do with redressing past grievances. The SOLE basis for preferential treatment for URM (underrepresented in medicine) groups is that black and hispanic patients tend to report higher rates of satisfaction with doctors of the same race. Finally for conservatives obsessed with only talking about affirmative action as it pertains to Asians - Asian and White medical school matriculants have the same GPA and Asians only have a slightly higher MCAT (which I would honestly attribute to the fact that Asians are more likely to reside in states with more competitive medical schools, thus necessitating higher MCAT scores to have a chance at acceptance) Source: https://www.aamc.org/media/6066/download?attachment

Expand full comment
Poinzy's avatar

The patients aren't "dead." They're "differently lived." Another way to put it is that the hospital has achieved "breathing diversity."

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts